Oral Culture to Early Print
Culture:
Memory Machines, Information Design, Economics
of Media Systems
Some Features of Oral
Cultural Transmission:
Oral Tradition as Memory
Machine
-
Beowulf and Homer's epics:
manuscript/scribal culture represents an oral poet:
-
The oral poet keeps "deep history" in memory:
Beowulf
(original Old English)
-
The voice of the oral poet as oracle: poet
authenticated by divine inspiration:
Homer's Iliad
I and Odyssey
I (Greek:
"andra moi ennepe musa...").
-
The Bible as memory machine: basic oral memory
features: parallelism and repetition: see online
versions of the Bible (Genesis, Psalms).
-
Oral culture meets literate, manuscript culture:
the Beowulf
manuscript: folio 129r, the first leaf of the manuscript. Copied c.1000
in England. In Old English.
Plato, Writing, Memory, and Computers: After
Ong, Chapter 4
-
Speech, voice, writing, and technological
interventions: alphabetic writing systems.
-
Plato already in literate, scribal
culture: see Phaedrus.
-
Privileging speech--the present, real-time
speech of dialogue--as underlying model of communication, thought, culture,
politics.
-
Are writing systems, and technological extensions
of writing like computer text--extensions of speech or voice?
Problems in "Oral Culture" Theory
-
Romantic nostalgia for pre-literate, pre-technological
cultures: fantasies of organic societies cohering with bond of the present
voice.
-
Models for social transitions and cultural
hybrids are needed rather than binary oppositions (oral vs. literate culture).
-
In Western cultures since around 800 A.D.,
illiterate people have been expected to participate in literate culture
(laws, scripture, literature read aloud to them).
-
Literacy has thus become the norm through
which culture, history, religion, and law are known (even for illiterate
people in literate societies).
-
Literate culture knows, subsumes, and can
represent (in writing) oral culture and oral communication practices, but
oral culture has no analogous knowledge or representational power for literate
culture.
-
Writing (handwritten or print) is a technology,
part of the built human world through tools.
The
First Information Age:
Manuscript
Culture, c.400-c.1500
The
technologies of manuscript production
and
the culture of the manuscript book
The Rise of the Codex Book
-
Form of the book adopted almost universally
in the West by 400 AD, replacing the book as "volume" (roll).
-
Materiality of the book: each manuscript was
a unique object.
-
Information in the medium: cultural/social
information in the material form of the codex book, its use and reception
throughout history.
-
"Writing" in the Western world from c.100-1500
A.D. usually meant dictating aloud to a secretary, who wrote a draft on
wax tablets, then a scribe copied the tablets onto parchment.
-
Book production and use formed an economic
and social system. The written languages were always the "official culture"
(Latin, Greek), not the commonly spoken languages.
-
Book production tied to a specific kind of
literacy. Books in different genres had different formats, look and feel.
Continues to today.
10th century idealization of St. Gregory writing
and scribed copying his books.
The Page as information
system: Format and layout of the page
-
Semiotics of the page: center and margins,
columns, hierarchies of script.
Manuscript culture and early "hypertext":
the page as system of meaning
-
Text and glosses or commentary, Bible with
gloss. Text with illustration. Text embedding and linking before hypertext.
-
Example
1: Donatus, Ars grammatica, copied at Rheims, c.875.
-
Example
2: Virgil, Aeneid, copied in Italy, c. 990.
Desire to extend the physical/material
limits of a text, combining script, decoration, and images.
Books and Universities:
Case Study: The Copying System for University Student's Books, 1175-1400
(the pecia system)
[T]he nascent universities created a new
reading public. New texts, reference works, and commentaries were required
for scholastic study, and these works were not the kind produced in monastic
scriptoria. The new secular book trade became a licensed appendage of the
university, consisting of stationers, scribes, parchment makers, paper
makers, bookbinders, and all those associated with making books. They enjoyed
certain rights such as an exemption from taxes and the right to be tried
in university courts. A stationer was appointed only after an inquiry to
confirm his good standing and professional ability. He had to provide guarantees
and take an oath. Books tended to be sold and resold through many generations
and it was the stationer's responsibility to sell a book and buy it back
and sell it again, and so forth. He could buy and sell only under certain
conditions: he had to advertise the titles he had in stock, prices were
fixed, and students and professors received discounts. In order to produce
the large numbers of textbooks required by students and maintain their
textual accuracy, the pecia system of copying was instituted. The system
began in about 1200 and ended in about 1350 in the North, and about 1425-50
in the South. It existed in at least eleven universities (seven in Italy,
two in France, and one each in Spain and England) and probably many others.
The stationer held one or more exact copies
(the exemplar) of a text in pieces (hence pecia), usually a gathering of
four folios (sixteen columns) or perhaps six folios. Each column had to
have a certain number of lines (usually sixty), and each line a certain
number of letters (usually thirty). Each exemplar was examined to ensure
it was correct, and any exemplar found to be incorrect resulted in a fine
for the stationer. Each part was rented out for a specific time (a week
at Bologna) so that students, or scribes, could copy them. This way a number
of students could be copying parts of the same book at the same time. Stationers
were required to rent pieces to anyone who requested them, and the charges
were fixed (e.g., at Treviso in 1318 the charges were six pence for copying,
and two pence for correcting). The size of books began to decline, and
script became more compact and the number of abbreviations increased. The
two-column format became the norm, and ornament was almost abandoned on
all books with the exception of the luxury trade. Soft cover bindings tended
to replace wooden boards, and parchment became progressively thinner as
the number of folios per gathering increased. [From Richard
Clement, Medieval and Renaissance Book Production:
I. Manuscript Books]
-
What was the economic system of the early
university book? Interesting model of production and labor in the hands
of the customer.
-
Most non-university copying houses did book
copying for hire. Most books from 1200 on were commissioned.
Further sources:
Medieval and Renaissance
Book Production:
I. Manuscript Books and II. Printed
Books (Richard Clement, University of Kansas)
The Making of Print Culture:
Better Memory Machines, or
Expanding the Centrality of the Codex Book
-
14th-15th centuries: though literacy remained
class and institution-based, a growing urban--and secular--literate class
began to emerge in European cities by the end of the 14th century.
-
Latin textual culture already established
through "grammatical culture" and the trivium (grammar, rhetoric, logic).
-
Emergence of the "private reader" and silent
reading. Demand for books.
-
Converging industries: paper, metals, pressing
devices.
-
Church's book culture expanding to secular
society.
-
Diffusion of the textual ideology of "humanism"
through standardized Latin books.
-
Diffusion of continental Reformation: Luther's
and Calvin's theological and political ideas depended on printed books.
-
What were the earliest printed books? Bibles,
liturgical (church) books like Psalters, private devotional books (Books
of Hours), classical authors (Homer, Virgil), school textbooks (especially
grammar; Gutenburg published several editions of Donatus's Ars grammatica,
the standard Latin grammar book).
-
Printing and language standarization: variations
of manuscript culture regularized.
-
Spread of vernacular, national languages through
print and standardization. Other effect: solidifying nationalisms and ideologies
through broad dissemination of standardized texts.
Ideology of the Book and
Private Reading Experience
Richard
de Bury's, Philobiblon (written 1345) (Richard was Chancellor
of England under Richard III and Bishop of Durham):
In books I find the dead as if
they were alive; in books I foresee things to come; in books warlike affairs
are set forth; from books come forth the laws of peace. All things are
corrupted and decay in time; Saturn ceases not to devour the children that
he generates; all the glory of the world would be buried in oblivion, unless
God had provided mortals with the remedy of books.
....
For the meaning of the voice perishes
with the sound; truth latent in the mind is wisdom that is hid and treasure
that is not seen; but truth which shines forth in books desires to manifest
itself to every impressionable sense. It commends itself to the sight when
it is read, to the hearing when it is heard, and moreover in a manner to
the touch, when it suffers itself to be transcribed, bound, corrected,
and preserved. The undisclosed truth of the mind, although it is the possession
of the noble soul, yet because it lacks a companion, is not certainly known
to be delightful, while neither sight nor hearing takes account of it.
Further the truth of the voice is patent only to the ear and eludes the
sight, which reveals to us more of the qualities of things, and linked
with the subtlest of motions begins and perishes as it were in a breath.
But the written truth of books, not transient but permanent, plainly offers
itself to be observed, and by means of the pervious spherules of the eyes,
passing through the vestibule of perception and the courts of imagination,
enters the chamber of intellect, taking its place in the couch of memory,
where it engenders the eternal truth of the mind. (Philobiblon,
Chap. 1)
The
Block Book: Printing before movable type.
Johann Gutenberg's innovation: printing
from hand-cast metal alloy type (probably lead, tin, and antinomy, which
had a low melting point and quick solidification) in large quantities,
on hand presses with oil-based ink.
Gutenberg's hand press. (From the
Gutenberg
Museum, Mainz.)
Gutenberg's famous 42-line (double column)
Bible printed in 1456 on six presses simultaneously, Mainz, Germany. (See
a close-up of the opening to St.
Paul's Epistle to the Romans.)
The first printed Psalter (Psalms):
Mainz, 1457. As You can see, the first printed books imitated manuscripts,
a fact that exemplifies McLuhan's theory that the content of a new medium
is an immediately prior medium.
-
Standardization of typography and page design:
regional variations gave way to "roman" type font, from prestige of the
humanist
movement in Italy and early classical Latin printed books: example
1; example
2.
-
The continuing authority of the page: page
layout, type design; personal portable object.
The Legacy of the Book
-
Continued economic system of publishing, literacy,
social experience and value of the book.
-
Deconstruct a Web "page": continuities from
early books, expectations of literate culture. Print publishing and multimedia
convergence, new ecosystem of media types. Significance of print book metaphors
for digital media.
Martin
Irvine, 1999 |