Field Research.
Margaret
Mead, the only anthropologist (or
sociologist)
to get her own postage stamp, won fame through field work, primarily her
book Coming
of Age in Samoa. Later, this book was denounced by anthropologist
Derek Freeman in his book Margaret
Mead and the Heretic : The Making and Unmaking of an Anthropological Myth.Anthropologists
have come to Mead's defense, and
have restudied the case, but I would have to agree with your text that
"had Mead come back from Samoa with an accurate ethnographic report, it
would not have made her famous." Here is the NY Times Review of Freeman's
critique of Mead.
More recently, there has been a raging controversy about the book Darkness
in El Dorado about research on the Yanomamo in Venezuela is the latest
ethical controversy, which also raises important methodological questions.
Many of the book's allegations, however, have
been contested by the National Academy of Sciences.
The combining
of fiction with factual research is increasingly common both in anthropology
and in biographies. Sometimes this is
openly
done as a literary form, in other cases such as that of Rigoberta Menchu,
it is only admitted when critics discover it.
There
are many problems with field research: ethical issues, problems of
reliability and validity when data are gathered by only one researcher,
etc. A controversial book is Laud Humphrey's Tea
Room Trade, which raises ethical issues. He studied gay sex in a men's
room in a park in St. Louis, without informing the participants what he
was doing.
Field researchers sometimes seem to find examples that fit their preconceptions,
and their work is often ignored by those who do not like the results, e.g.,
Leon Dash's book When
Children Want Children and
Rosa Lee which are just ignored by welfare advocates who prefer
more sympathetic treatments. One of the best field studies is
Kathryn Edin's book Making
Ends Meet. which is highly sympathetic to the mothers. However,
Edin collected statistical data as well her illustrative observations.
The statistics showed that almost none of the mothers actually lived off
their grants alone. Eli Anderson's book Streetwise
on men in a Philadelphia ghetto has been well received, in large part because
goes beyond one-sided advocacy.
A great strength of field work is observing behaviors that the people themselves
don't understand or aren't even aware of., or at any event, are unable
or unwilling to talk about. Anthropologist Jules
Henry spent a week living in each of the homes of several children
who had grown up mentally ill, trying to discern patterns in the family
interactions that contributed to the illness. Myra Bluebond-Langner's
book The
Private Worlds of Dying Children has been very influential; she
has just published a sequel called In
the Shadow of Illness : Parents and Siblings of the Chronically Ill Child
Field reserch offers a richness of description and possibility of new insights
that is unparalled by any other method. Unless it is supplemented
with other methods, it does not provide statistical data, and it is hard
to replicate.,