|
Broadcasting to the choir
For more and more TV channels and
radio stations, the format is all Jesus, all the time. But
non-Christians are tuning out.
By Paul Nussbaum
Inquirer Staff Writer
VIRGINIA BEACH, Va. - With the seconds ticking
away to air time, news anchor Wendy Griffith had adjusted her
microphone, retouched her makeup, practiced the tough pronunciations,
taken a last sip of water. It was time for a final check - with God.
As the crew and staff bowed their heads, Griffith
prayed, first for the victims of Hurricane Katrina, and then for a
successful broadcast: "We ask you to be with us and that things will go
smoothly, and that through our show, people out there will get to know
you better."
The Christian Broadcasting Network's daily program, CBN
NewsWatch, which presents the news through a conservative Protestant
prism, is one of the latest entries in the growing universe of
evangelical Christian broadcasting.
On radio and TV, on cable and satellite, evangelicals
have become a 24-hour-a-day presence with preaching, music,
entertainment, talk and news.
Evangelical programs offer a refuge from sex, violence,
profanity and liberals. The news shows find silver linings behind grim
headlines. The talk shows push familiar hot buttons - family values,
abortion, Israel, activist judges, moral decay. With their unabashed
references to Jesus and salvation, the programs speak a language
familiar to evangelicals, and with their loyal audiences, they provide
a reliable, quickly mobilized political force for conservative leaders.
But polls show the programs may be more effective at
fortifying the faithful than converting the skeptics. The number of
non-Christian listeners to Christian radio has dropped by a third since
1992.
The growth in the number of religious stations has been
marked: Of 13,838 radio stations in the United States, 2,014 are
religious stations, according to Arbitron Inc., the media research
company. That's up from 1,089 stations among 12,840 in 1998, according
to Arbitron. Salem Communications Corp., of Camarillo, Calif, the
biggest owner of Christian stations, owns 104 radio stations in the
country, including WFIL-AM (560) and WNTP-AM (990) in the Philadelphia
market, and syndicates programming to 1,900 affiliates.
On television, Christian networks have proliferated,
such as CBN (home of Pat Robertson and The 700 Club); the
nation's largest religious network, Trinity Broadcasting; Inspiration
Network; Daystar; SkyAngel; Three Angels Broadcasting; World Harvest
Television; Cornerstone Television; Praise TV; Worship Channel; Gospel
Music Television; The Word Network, and FamilyNet.
"If you wanted to, you could immerse yourself 24 hours a
day in religious programming in nearly every radio market in the
country or with cable television or with satellite TV," said Quentin J.
Schultze, author of Televangelism in America: The Business of
Popular Religion and a professor of communication at Calvin
College, an evangelical liberal-arts school in Grand Rapids, Mich. The
most popular topic on the programs, he said, is personal salvation, and
the second-most popular is "whatever is a source of conflict in the
general media."
Evangelical broadcasters can help set the nation's
agenda to an extent beyond the size of their audience.
"Because most Americans don't contact their public
leaders, when religious broadcasters ask listeners to do so, they can
make a tremendous difference," Schultze said. "Since the Reagan era,
the religious conservatives have been able to set so much of the public
discourse agenda."
Americans have grown more receptive to Christian
broadcasting, said Rob Kirkpatrick, executive director of broadcasting
and operations for Focus on the Family, where broadcaster James
Dobson's radio show draws about two million listeners a day and his TV
commentary about 686,000 daily viewers.
"I think there is a shift occurring culturally,"
Kirkpatrick said. "I think a desire for wholesomeness is returning."
"We bring a spiritual dimension that is needed," said
Robertson, whose 700 Club had an average of 863,000 viewers
daily during the 2004-05 TV season, according to Nielsen Media
Research. Robertson launched the daily CBN NewsWatch in March 2003 as
an adjunct to The 700 Club. The one-time presidential candidate
often appears as an interviewer or commentator on the news show, and he
praises the show's difference from secular programs: "We don't just
report problems on our news. We try to fix them."
(Robertson recently sparked controversy by calling for
the assassination of Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez; Robertson
apologized the next day.)
Despite the increase in outlets, the number of daily
listeners and viewers remains relatively small. Religious radio draws
about 5.5 percent of the audience, up from 2.2 percent five years ago.
Monthly numbers are much larger: The National Religious Broadcasters, a
trade association, says more people use Christian media than attend
church; 46 percent of American adults reported in a survey in April
that they listen to a Christian radio broadcast and 45 percent watch
Christian TV in a typical month.
Numbers of religious TV viewers are not as accurately
tracked as radio listeners, but may average five million daily,
estimated Philip Goff, director of the Center for the Study of Religion
and American Culture at Indiana University.
By comparison, the most popular TV entertainment
programs, such as CSI and The Simpsons, draw more than
10 million viewers each. There are about 109.6 million households with
televisions in the United States, according to Nielsen.
The widespread use of radio, TV, and now, the Internet,
Goff said, is just the latest demonstration of evangelicals' grasp of
technology to spread their message, building on a tradition that
started in the 19th century with mass printings of religious tracts.
"I think it's going to continue to transform," Goff
said. "The Web is going to be more and more useful." And he cited
another recent development: the linking of large evangelical
congregations in national radio and TV simulcasts to advance political
agendas, as with Justice Sunday and Justice Sunday II, which rallied
evangelicals earlier this year to support conservative judges.
"Evangelical TV mirrors the larger culture," said Bill
Leonard, dean of the Wake Forest Divinity School and a professor of
church history. "It takes the same elements and Christianizes them. You
have Christian soap operas, dramas, talk shows, music - even Christian
heavy metal."
So, on a show such as CBN's NewsWatch, reporters may
cover many of the same stories as their secular counterparts, but with
a distinctly Christian perspective. Recent reports from the
hurricane-ravaged Gulf Coast, for instance, touched on body counts and
criticisms of the government, but also prominently featured Marines
clearing fallen timber, Christian teens dishing out hot meals, CBN
reporters praying with victims, and the medical donations of Operation
Blessing - Robertson's own charitable organization.
"We try not to do stories that are just the downers,"
said Robert Allman, news director for the show. "We hopefully spend as
much time on the hopeful aspects."
"We have no house fires, car chases, or drive-by
shootings," said Allman, noting the distinctions between CBN and a
Dallas CBS station where he used to work. "We did not run a Michael
Jackson story till the verdict."
A recent segment on the Senate hearings on Supreme Court
nominee John G. Roberts Jr. featured not only the predictable
sound-bite exchanges between Roberts and committee members, but also a
pro-Roberts analysis by Jay Sekulow, chief counsel of the
Robertson-created American Center for Law and Justice.
"I work for a ministry," Allman said. "We're going for
viewers, but we have a greater purpose."
"We cover the same things, up to a certain point. Then
we may take a right turn about how people are dealing with that issue."
In the Philadelphia area, Comcast offers five religious
channels - the Inspiration, Trinity, and Word networks; WGTW, a
Trinity-owned local station, and the Catholic network, EWTN.
Here and around the nation, religious broadcasters tend
to preach to the choir. The vast majority of listeners to Christian
radio are born-again Christians, according to the Barna Group, a
Christian research organization. Christian television draws its
strength from people in their 60s and older, females, residents of the
South, African Americans, people with limited education and income, and
born-again Christians.
And non-Christians are increasingly tuning out: Just 28
percent of non-Christians surveyed in April ever listen to religious
radio, compared with 42 percent in 1992, according to Barna.
"Religious broadcasters talk about reaching beyond their
tribe, but they use language that only their tribe understands,"
Schultze said. "It seems like the American media, secular and
religious, are arenas for tribal bickering rather than trying to serve
the public good."
For more about the evangelical movement in America,
visit http://go.philly.com/religion.
|